April 2002

This issue:

Archives of Past Issues | Subscribe


 

CRC NEWS

ANNOUNCEMENT
The CRC is proud to announce that its CEO, Professor Ian Noble FTSE, has been selected for a senior position with the World Bank in Washington DC. From June 2002, Ian Noble will assume the role of Chief Technical Adviser to the new "Bio-carbon Fund". The BCF, modelled on the very successful "Prototype Carbon Fund", is designed to benchmark the market for high-quality removal of greenhouse gases in forest and agro-ecosystems. It will seek to create carbon assets that enhance biodiversity protection,
help fight against desertification, and support socio-economic development. BCF will also take a long-term view, seeking to understand how a wider range of developing countries might become engaged in reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

The recent appointment of Prof Noble to the World Bank is clear recognition of the high regard in which he and his scientific expertise are held both nationally and internationally. Ian's appointment strongly augments the CRC's international linkages and his continued involvement with the development of IPCC Good Practice Guidelines in Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry will continue to ensure that CRC research is brought forward in this vital area of carbon accounting. The staff of the CRC warmly wish him all the very best in his new endeavours.

The CRC Governing Board has appointed Dep-CEO, Dr Chris Mitchell as A/g CEO until such time as a new Chief Executive is appointed by the Board. Chris may be contacted on chris.mitchell@greenhouse.crc.org.au

CRC RESEARCH INTO GRASSLANDS & CO2
This month, Prof William Stock, a CRC member from Cape Town University, presented some of his research into the natural grasslands of South Africa. Each year since 1996, Prof Stock has left his Cape Town office in the southern-most part of Sth Africa and travelled 2000kms NE to Natal Province. His goal? To study the effect of 70 years of exposure to elevated carbon dioxide (CO2) on the growth and development of what are known as "C4 grasslands".

C4 Grasslands (eg. maize, sugar cane and other highly productive crops) are of considerable interest to the CRC because they account for 3% of all plant species and approx 21% of global primary production of biomass. Like Sth Africa, Australia's grasslands are predominantly "C4" in type which means they are found mostly in tropical regions, unlike "C3" grasses which are found in temperate areas. Generally speaking, the terms "C4" and "C3" refer to differences in photosynthetic type.

The Natal study area features many common species of native grasses and is used for rangelands. The field site itself comprises a 5m x 5m grassy plot in the middle of which is a pipe, or CO2 "SOURCE", that juts a foot or two out of the ground. Out of the pipe, sunk by a bottling company in the thirties but not used, come plumes of naturally-occurring CO2 (at 5-10m from the pipe, the CO2 concentration in the air is 500ppm). The CO2 is made by acid leaching down to underground limestone chemically creating the gas that then seeps up and out of the ground. The source itself is a natural fault line called the "Bongwan Gas Fault" that runs for approx. 50kms, in places along the Umzumkulu River. This river and the surrounding land are home to the KwaZulu who were first aware of the natural phenomenon that sends bubbles rising from the river bed.

Conclusions: Prof Stock concluded by remarking upon how this study clearly revealed the scientific difficulties inherent in extrapolating results from the smaller to the larger scale. Essentially, what was found to be the case at the leaf-level in the lab was found not to hold at the ecosystem-level for this site. So, for example, the marked growth noted in lab plants under conditions of elevated CO2 were not repeated in the field where other factors such as disturbances from fire, for example, are presumed to have a major impact on plant growth and development. Despite laboratory experiments predicting likely results to the contrary, Prof Stock noted that to date there had been dramatic change in common species type; no major functional change (ie the grasslands have not transformed over time into shrubland or forest); and no CO2 fertilisation (ie no significant growth responses). What was noted in the first parts of the growing season, however, was that the speed and development of the grasses had increased yet there was no change to the final biomass (ie no increase in the final carbon STOCK). There was also no change to soil organic matter, although there was some indication of changes to processes of N mineralisation and C respiration. For more info, please Email william.stock@greenhouse.crc.org.au. [talk summarised by R Mueller, any errors are her own]

********************
The CRC also warmly congratulates one of its scientists, Dr Richard Harper of Conservation & Land Management, WA, who was recently awarded an Adjunct Associate Professorship by The University of Western Australia.


NEWS

Reminders:
COP 8, New Delhi, India, 23 October to 1 November 2002 See: http://unfccc.int/wnew/index.html

AUSTRALIAN GREENHOUSE OFFICE FAREWELLS INAUGURAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE
Environment-news, Issue 26: http://www.ea.gov.au/minister/env/2002/mr05apr202.html
The Minister for the Environment and Heritage, Dr David Kemp, announced this month that Ms Gwen Andrews, Chief Executive of the Australian Greenhouse Office (AGO), intends to leave her position early in May. Ms Andrews is coming to the end of her second contract period as Chief Executive of the AGO. "Ms Andrews led the establishment of the AGO and has been with the organisation for its first four years.She deserves a great deal of credit for the successful delivery of the range of programs that the Government has put in place to combat climate change.

The AGO is known internationally for its ground-breaking work and Ms Andrews is widely recognised both nationally and internationally for her expertise in this area," Dr Kemp said. The AGO's achievements include the establishment of the world's first national market in renewable energy under the Government's Mandatory Renewable Energy Target, the implementation of the Greenhouse Gas Abatement Program, progressing development of market mechanisms and establishing solid accounting procedures, especially in land clearing and forestry.

US DEAL DOES NOT RULE OUT KYOTO SIGNATURE
By Dr David Kemp, Aust. Fed Minister for Environment & Heritage. This is an edited excerpt from his address to the Ian Clunies Ross Foundation - March 7.

The Canberra Times
http://canberra.yourguide.com.au/detail.asp?class=features&subclass=science&category=feature& story_id=137701&y=2002&m=3
See also: Dept of the Env & Heritage: http://www.ea.gov.au/minister/index.html

SUSTAINABILITY is something we can all agree on in theory, and acceptance of the concept is now very widespread in our communities and in most of our industries. In practice, achieving the condition of sustainability is, as they say, something else, and here communication and leadership are vital.
Sustainability has not only local, regional and national expressions but it has a global dimension as well. If securing the sustainability of the Murray-Darling Basin is a huge challenge, how much more so is achieving sustainability in the global systems that affect us all. The debate about global warming illustrates how complex such issues can be. The new Climate Action Partnership with the United States - agreed on my visit to Washington last month - emphasises three imperatives:

  • the need for a deeper scientific understanding of the problems we confront;
  • practical measures involving the development of new, effective technological solutions;
  • and the effective engagement of industry as well as the developing countries in what is truly the most global of issues.

The Howard Government has pledged to work towards meeting its commitments under the Kyoto Protocol. Australia is also firmly of the belief that only a global response will yield effective results. And any successful approach must seek to minimise the costs and maximise the incentives for technological change. One of the weaknesses of Kyoto in what is known as the first commitment period up to 2012 is the absence from the arrangements of the US and developing countries whose contributions of greenhouse gases during the next decade will be greater than those from developed countries. Even the Europeans accept that there will be no second- commitment period without the participation of the major developing countries. And without the US no approach can be genuinely global. All of us understand that technology will be crucial to meeting climate objectives in a way that is consistent with legitimate expectations about living standards around the world. It was in this context that we saw in President Bush's statement of the US position an opportunity for Australia to engage with the United States. The statement puts technology front and centre in efforts to reduce the American impact on global warming. The Bush approach also recognises that developing countries will have aspirations for economic growth and that companies that take early action at home or abroad to reduce their emissions should have the
opportunity to have those reductions officially reflected in a register.

Whatever Australia decides to do on ratification - and we have not made any decision on that as yet - it is clear there will be a period when there will be two approaches operating: the Kyoto system and the US policy model. This could bring with it costs and risks of investment distortions for international companies,
including our own, and for jobs if it is not handled very carefully. And it is equally important that the existence of two approaches should not get in the way of good work on science and technology. So in our agreement with US on a Climate Action Partnership we have put as a high priority work on internationally harmonised carbon accounting systems. These will be very important for companies that operate internationally, in Kyoto and non-Kyoto countries, and that will seek recognition for greenhouse gas abatement actions that they have undertaken, wherever they have taken them.

We have to work hard to make sure that accounting rules put in place in the next few years in Kyoto and non-Kyoto countries do not make it harder to achieve a genuinely global approach in the longer run. 'There will be a period when there will be two approaches operating: the Kyoto system and the US policy model' Australia has already done some world-leading work on carbon accounting through the Australian Greenhouse Office, and the Americans indicated their interest in this work as they begin developing
standardised and transparent registration for their enterprises. Again, it is important that work on the fundamental issues of the underlying climate science and the technology to deal with climate change is accelerated, not slowed in the years ahead.

We aim, under the partnership, to pursue opportunities for our scientists and enterprises to engage with American counterparts on these key issues. We did not enter into our Climate Action Partnership with the United States as an alternative to the Kyoto protocol. It will be an important part of our overall greenhouse efforts whether the Kyoto Protocol comes into force or not. We will not be rushed into a decision on ratification. That decision will require careful consideration of the full range of environmental, economic and social implications of the Protocol.

GERMANY BEGINS KYOTO TREATY RATIFICATION
BBC: http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/world/europe/newsid_1887000/1887961.stm
Germany has become the first major industrialised country to begin formally ratifying the Kyoto Protocol on climate change. The lower house of parliament voted unanimously to make the treaty part of German law. The country will commit itself to reduce its emissions of carbon dioxide by a fifth by the year 2012. The upper chamber of the parliament is due to make a final decision on ratification next month. European Union environment ministers have pledged to ratify the treaty by August, in the lead-up to the World Summit on Environment and Development in Johannesburg. The EU is leading a campaign to persuade other industrialised countries to join it in ratifying the protocol. These must include Russia and Japan. Without them, and without the United States which withdrew from Kyoto last year, the treaty will not have the support of enough of the world's major polluters to become international law. See also:
Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung:
http://www.faz.com/IN/INtemplates/eFAZ/archive.asp?doc ={C81CC495-E28F-46A4-B256-D8082ECD48EE} &width=1024&height=740&agt=explorer&ver=4&svr=4
Deutschlandfunk Radio:
http://globalarchive.ft.com/globalarchive/article.html?id=020322003299&query%22kyoto+protocol%22

Related item:
CONFERENCE ON EU AND GERMAN CLIMATE POLICY - CHALLENGES BEFORE THE ENTRY
INTO FORCE OF THE KYOTO PROTOCOL
: This meeting will be held from 6-8 May 2002, in Hamburg, Germany. Organized by the Hamburg Institute of International Economics, the conference will focus on the ratification of the Kyoto Protocol in the EU, challenges with regard to EU national climate strategies, internal EU emissions trading, integration of EU accession countries, the role of the Kyoto mechanisms, and EU strategies for achieving entry into force. For more information, contact: Axel Michaelowa, Hamburg Institute of International Economics; tel: +49-404-283-4309; fax: +49-404-283-4451; e-mail: michaelowa@hwwa.de; Internet: http://www.hwwa.de/climate.htm


WHATS ON THE WEB

(3 May, 2002)
Carbonopoly: Play an interactive emissions trading market simulation game
Contact: Sonya Williams, Sustainable Energy Development Authority of NSW (SEDA) on Ph 02 9249 6122 Email swilliams@seda.nsw.gov.au
SEDA's computer model based simulation offers participants the opportunity to become 'Players' in a hypothetical emissions market involving emission abatement, sequestration and permit trading to better their positions. Players trade in small teams representing a diverse range of Australian industries and other stakeholders. The computer-based model calculates the current financial and emission status for each Player. Players use a paper-based system to encourage team negotiations and discussions. The day will begin with breakfast talks on the current status of current climate change negotiations and an Introduction to Emissions Trading. Date: 3 May Venue: SEDA Boardroom, Level 6, 45 Clarence St. Further details http://www.seda.nsw.gov.au/events_body.asp

Carbon Contracts Cornerstones - Drafting Contracts for the Sale of Project-Based Emission Reductions
Contact: Robert Dornau on dornau@ieta.org Download at http://www.ieta.org.
The paper was produced by IETA Member Baker & McKenzie as a common starting point for the preparation of Carbon Contracts in the carbon trading market. The objective is to begin the process of standardizing the Carbon Contract process to help facilitate trades and emissions projects by streamlining the contractual process so helping to reduce transaction cost. It is envisaged that this Paper will mark the beginnings of a process to develop standardized carbon contracts for different types of transactions. This process will it is hoped develop and mature alongside the carbon market

Canada's Baseline Protection Initiative (BPI) - On-Line Registration
Contact: bpi.ppnr@nrcan.gc.ca
As of April 10, 2002, Canadian organisations may visit the BPI web site and register on-line actions they have taken since January 1, 1990, to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Orgs can register with the BPI or update their files without administrative delays by going to http://www.vcr-mvr.ca of Canada's Climate Change Voluntary Challenge and Registry Inc. (VCR Inc.) or http://www.ecogeste.gouv.qc.ca of the Bureau d'enregistrement des mesures volontaires sur les changements climatiques (ÉcoGESte) in Québec. The BPI is an initiative under Canada's First National Climate Change Business Plan that was announced by federal, provincial and territorial energy and environment ministers in October 2000. Registrants in the BPI can have their emissions baselines adjusted to reflect the reduction actions they
have taken since January 1, 1990.

US Global Change Research Program Website: What's New
Contact: Nick Sundt, USGCRP Information & Outreach; Email: nsundt@usgcrp.gov Web: www.usgcrp.gov
http://www.usgcrp.gov/usgcrp/new.htm The page is updated 1-2 times each month. Some recent items include:

  • Depths Of The Southern Ocean Being Starved Of Oxygen." Press release (19 March 2002) from UniSci.
  • Antarctic ice shelf collapses in largest event of last 30 years." Press release (18 March 2002) from Univ of Colorado, USA.
  • The Economic Implications of an El Nino." Press release (6 March 2002) National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
  • Future Volcanic Eruptions May Cause Ozone Hole Over Arctic." Press release (4 March 2002) from NASA's Earth Observing System.
  • Aerosols Found to Brighten Clouds." Press release (dtd 28 Feb 2002) from Brookhaven National Lab, USA.
  • Tree Ring Records Link Historic Epidemics to Drought." Press release (25 Feb 2002) from Univ of Arkansas, USA.

REMOTE SENSING OF FORESTS - PROJECT INFO FROM CANADA
At the GIS and Land Resource Lab of Trent University, Peterborough, Ontario, Canada, researchers have completed two projects directly related to the application of remote sensing techniques to forestry resources: The projects are related to the measurement of carbon stock in tropical forest biomass and on the assessment, measurement and mapping of plant diversity in the same tropical forests the relationship to landscape fragmentation. [CC & Forestry 3/2002, http://www.fao.org/forestry/climate]

Project 1: "Estimation of Tropical Forest Above-ground Biomass by Multispectral Remote Sensing".
M.Sc. thesis of J. Galarza. Watershed Ecosystems Graduate Program, Trent University. (To be posted at http://www.trentu.ca/gis).
Accurate estimates of tropical forests' biomass density are required for inventory and monitoring of carbon sinks in terrestrial ecosystems on a regional and global basis. Procedures for the estimation of tropical
forest above ground biomass using multispectral remote sensing techniques supported by ground measurements were investigated. A stratified sampling scheme was used to place quadrat sampling sites on the ground, using the classes from a supervised classification of the Landsat Thematic Mapper image of the area, as the strata for sampling. Standard regression equations of biomass as a function of allometric measurements of trees, obtained from quadrat sites on the ground, were fitted to the data.

The spectral response (i.e. Digital Numbers (DNS), radiance and reflectance) of three different multispectral waveband ratios (NDVI, GVI and NDWI) computed from the Landsat TM image was correlated to biomass as measured in the field, yielding relative strong associations. Three predictive models of biomass as a function of spectral response parameters (DNs, radiance and reflectance) of the band ratio images were created to estimate above ground biomass. The results revealed that the best
predictive models of biomass were exponential functions of the DNs of a GVI band ratio image resampled to match the resolution of quadrat sites on the ground. Maps of image ground biomass in tropical forests were created using the reflectance properties of the GVI image and the equations developed. Respective maps of expected standard error of estimates from regression were also created as an indication of the spatial distribution of the expected accuracy of biomass estimates from the developed models.

Project 2: "Mapping the spatial distribution of plant diversity indices of tropical forests using multi-spectral satellite image analysis and field measurements".
Ph.D. research of J.L. Hernandez-Stefanoni. Watershed Ecosystems Graduate Program. Trent University.
The relationships between standard plant diversity indices (species richness, exponential Shannon diversity index, reciprocal Simpson, Margalef index and reciprocal Berger-Parker) computed from 73 randomly selected (10x10m) sampling quadrat sites of vegetation in a tropical forest of the Yucatan, Mexico, and the landscape element types, as obtained by a supervised Maximum Likelihood classification of a Landsat Thematic Mapper multi-spectral image, are examined in order to derive quantitative estimates of biodiversity over the entire landscape, from the limited number of quadrat sites sampled. A relatively high map accuracy of the vegetation classes map produced, was revealed by the overall accuracy assessment and the Cohen's Kappa statistic.

A standard one-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) of the diversity indices over the classes defined by multispectral analysis of the satellite image, as criteria in the ANOVA, confirmed a statistically significant reduction of the within-class variance of the diversity indices with respect of their total variance across the landscape. Computed Uniformity Indices (U) measuring the internal uniformity of vegetation classes on the diversity indices confirmed the goodness of the mapped classes in stratifying variability of the diversity indices, and therefore, allowing for the use of the mapped classes as mechanism for spatial interpolation, prediction and upscaling of the quadrat- site computed biodiversity indices to the entire landscape studied. The examination of the spatial variability of the plant diversity indices with the mapped vegetation classes allowed to establish a pattern of relationships between the diversity indices and the various stages of tropical sub-deciduous forest succession, as represented by the landscape element types or vegetation classes identified and mapped from the multispectral satellite image classification.


NEW PUBLICATIONS

Science policy: Policy, politics and perspective
by Roger A Pielke Jr. Nature 416, 367 - 368 (2002) The scientific community must distinguish analysis from advocacy.

Ecological responses to recent climate change
by Walther and Post et al. Nature 416, 389 - 395 (2002) - E-mail: walther@geobotanik.uni-hannover.de
There is now ample evidence of the ecological impacts of recent climate change, from polar terrestrial to tropical marine environments. The responses of both flora and fauna span an array of ecosystems and
organizational hierarchies, from the species to the community levels. Despite continued uncertainty as to community and ecosystem trajectories under global change, our review exposes a coherent pattern of ecological change across systems. Although we are only at an early stage in the projected trends of global warming, ecological responses to recent climate change are already clearly visible.

GONDWANA to GREENHOUSE
AUSTRALIAN ENVIRONMENTAL GEOSCIENCE: GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA - SPECIAL PUBLICATION No.21, Nov 2001.
Edited by: Assoc. Prof. Victor A. Gostin Department Geology & Geophysics, Adelaide University
Contact: Misha Frankel at misha@gsa.org.au
Theme 1 - Ancient Australia and environmental changes.
Theme 2 - Geohazards in urban communities
Theme 3 - Mining and Radioactivity
Theme 4 - Water and sedimentary basins
Chapter 11: Hydrogeology and environmental geology of the Great Artesian Basin, Australia.
Theme 5 - Coastal and nearshore environments

Carbon mitigation potential and costs of forestry options in Brazil, China, India, Indonesia, Mexico, the Philippines and Tanzania" Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 6 (3-4): 185-211, 2001 Copyright © 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers.
No electronic copy of the paper is available, please consult the printed journal. In this issue of the journal Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change titled "Forestry Mitigation Potential and Costs in
Developing Countries", a set of studies are presented that aim to estimate the (1) GHG emissions from these and neighboring countries, (2) potential for emissions avoidance and carbon sequestration, and (3) monetary and other costs and benefits of forestry mitigation options, and (4) to assess project opportunities. The countries studied are Brazil, China, India, Indonesia, Mexico, the Philippines and Tanzania.

This paper summarizes studies of carbon (C) mitigation potential and costs of about 40 forestry options in seven developing countries. Each study uses the same methodological approach - Comprehensive Mitigation Assessment Process (COMAP) - to estimate the above parameters between 2000 and 2030.
The approach requires the projection of baseline and mitigation land-use scenarios. Coupled with data on a per ha basis on C sequestration or avoidance, and costs and benefits, it allows the estimation of monetary benefit per Mg C, and the total costs and carbon potential. The results show that about half (3.0 Pg C) the cumulative mitigation potential of 6.2 Petagram (Pg) C between 2000 and 2030 in the seven countries (about 200× 106 Mg C yr-1) could be achieved at a negative cost and the remainder at costs ranging up to $100 Mg C-1. About 5 Pg C could be achieved, at a cost less than $20 per Mg C. Negative cost potential indicates that non-carbon revenue is sufficient to offset direct costs of these options. The
achievable potential is likely to be smaller, however, due to market, institutional and sociocultural barriers that can delay or prevent the implementation of the analysed options.

"Les instruments de la Convention-cadre sur les Changements Climatiques et leur potentiel pour le developpement durable de l' Afrique"
The working paper is currently being translated into English. Electronic version (in French) will shortly be available on the Forestry and Climate Change Web site http://www.fao.org/forestry/Climate/ The paper, produced by the FAO in cooperation with CIRAD, contains detailed discussions of UNFCCC and the Kyoto Protocol, of the CDM and of other funding possibilities for SFM of the Protocol. In addition, there is useful background information on Climate Change and forests, as well as proposals for practical implementation in Africa.

"Non-CO2 Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Developed Countries: 1990 - 2010"
[http://www.pewclimate.org/projects/trading.cfm]Contact: Elizabeth Scheehle - scheehle.elizabeth@epa.gov
This EPA document presents emissions and baseline projections of the non-CO2 gases from major anthropogenic sources for 38 developed countries. The report is available at http://www.epa.gov/ghginfo/reports

Greenhouse Gas Reporting and Disclosure: Key Elements of a Prospective U.S. Program
This policy 'In Brief' from the Pew Center on Global Climate Change USA provides guidance regarding the first step in any domestic program aimed at securing greenhouse gas emissions reductions: a mandatory greenhouse gas (GHG) reporting and disclosure program. The program outlined in this paper would ultimately track at least 75 percent of the human-induced GHG emissions in the United States, providing policy-makers and the public a sound basis for developing a comprehensive GHG reduction strategy, and
creating incentives for entities to reduce their GHG emissions. http://www.pewclimate.org/policy/index_ghg.cfm

INTERNATIONAL ENERGY OUTLOOK 2002
The full report of the International Energy Outlook 2002 has been released in PDF format (PDF - 2 meg). Provides an assessment of international energy markets with projections of worldwide energy consumption by fuel type and carbon emissions by regions to the year 2020. (HTML version of the
full report avail by April 30, 2002). See: ftp://ftp.eia.doe.gov/pub/pdf/international/0484(2002).pdf The Highlights Section of the International Energy Outlook 2002 provides an assessment of international energy markets with projections of worldwide energy consumption by fuel type and carbon emissions by regions to the year 2020. See: http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/ieo/index.html

UK Renewables Obligation Briefing Note
The recent launch of the RO marks the next stage in the UK government's plan to meet 10% of electricity needs from renewables by 2010. UK Tyndall Climate Change Centre researchers have produced a Briefing Note that introduces the new policy and sketches out some of the challenges that lie ahead in meeting the 2010 UK renewables target - from the electricity market, the planning system, established modes of energy regulation, and innovating in new renewable technologies. Available at http://www.tyndall.ac.uk/publications/briefing_notes/note04.shtml

The Emerging International Greenhouse Gas Market
by the Pew Center on Global Climate Change USA. The Solution Series report describes the characteristics of the emerging greenhouse gas market and key features of early trades. It also evaluates the potential evolution of the market due to ongoing domestic and international climate change policy
development and potential scenarios regarding the U.S. response to climate change. Full report and press release available at http://www.pewclimate.org

LINKING U.S. AND INTERNATIONAL CLIMATE CHANGE STRATEGIES
Pew Center on Global Climate Change USA at http://www.pewclimate.org/events/us_international_whitepaper.cfm
Working paper by Daniel Bodansky This paper identifies potential scenarios for the linkage of U.S. and international climate strategies; describes how emerging national and international emissions trading regimes will shape the context within which such linkages could take place; and examines issues that must be considered in the design of a U.S. climate strategy to ensure its compatibility with an international regime.

U.S. CLIMATE POLICY AFTER KYOTO: ELEMENTS FOR SUCCESS
Contact: Scott Nathanson at snathanson@ceip.org http://www.ceip.org/files/Publications/Bodansky_pb15.asp?from=pubdate
The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace has published a policy brief by Daniel Bodansky on US climate policy after Kyoto. According to the brief, the decision by the Bush administration to abandon the Kyoto Protocol and go its own way on climate change is not necessarily the disaster for climate policy often portrayed by environmentalists. Because Kyoto's success is far from assured, having alternative approaches is a prudent hedging strategy. The real disappointment has been the failure of the United States to develop a credible climate change policy of its own. In contrast to Kyoto-which tries to construct a comprehensive global architecture all at once-the US should proceed step by step, starting with domestic action and then moving outward, beginning with like-minded states. It should initially address fewer greenhouse gases and use relatively simple procedures. And it should employ a safety valve that caps costs to provide economic predictability and prevent unexpectedly high costs that would tempt countries not to comply. In the long run, the race to combat climate change will go to the most durable policy, not the speediest.

Evaluating the Bush Climate Change Initiative
From the Netherlands National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM)
Contact: André de Moor E-mail: andre.de.moor@rivm.nl RIVM web site: http://www.rivm.nl/ieweb/ieweb/index.html
The report provides an comprehensive evaluation of the President's proposal to reduce the greenhouse gas intensity of the US economy by 18 per cent between 2002 and 2012. It evaluates the proposed policy target by comparing it to historical trends and alternative baseline projections. Moreover, it compares the efforts under the Bush plan with those under the Kyoto Protocol, both in terms of environmental effectiveness and costs. The report also explores possible international climate policy implications of the Bush Initiative, in particular its plea for an intensity targets approach. The main conclusion is that the Bush Initiative proposes a very modest climate policy target for the US that is not comparable to the
efforts of the EU and Japan under the Kyoto Protocol, and offers no credible alternative to the Kyoto Protocol nor a basis for establishing an effective and acceptable international climate regime. At the same time, the proposal is of political significance as it explicitly accepts the importance of the climate change problem and the long-term objective of the Climate Change Convention. This improves the longer term prospects for US participation in a global climate change regime.

CICERO Annual Report (2001)
Oslo) http://www.cicero.uio.no/index_e.asp. The Centre for International Climate and Environmental Research, Oslo was founded by the Norwegian Govt in 1990 and is an independent research centre associated with the University of Oslo. CICERO's mandate is to conduct research and provide information about climate change. Pål Prestrud will take over as director of CICERO from June 3. Prestrud has worked with environmental issues affecting the polar regions for most of his professional career, in both a
research and an administrative capacity. He currently acts as vice-chair of ACIA (Arctic Climate Impact Assessment).Contact: Andreas Tjernshaugen, Tel +47 22 85 87 84;andreas.tjernshaugen@cicero.uio.no

Tomorrow's market: Global Trends and Their Implications for Business (UNEP/WBCSD/WRI)
Launched in April. Businesses that wish to survive and thrive in a global economy must respond to major social and environmental trends that are reshaping markets, says the report released by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD) and the World Resources Institute (WRI). Backed with facts and figures, the new report outlines 19 powerful trends that are reshaping global markets and changing the roles and strategies of
corporations. Tomorrow's Market: Global Trends and Their Implications for Business is the first publication that links global economic, environmental, and social indicators to market development in order to help
businesses better respond to future challenges.
Download report (large - l16MB) in PDF format at http://www.wbcsd.org/newscenter/reports/2002/tomorrows-market/tm_cover.pdf.
Download individual chapters at http://www.wbcsd.org/newscenter/releases/3march02.htm.

AGRICULTURE NEGOTIATIONS BACKGROUNDER THE ISSUES, AND WHERE WE ARE NOW
WORLD TRADE ORG
Website: http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/agric_e/negs_bkgrnd00_contents_e.htm


SEMINARS & CONFERENCES

REQUEST FOR SUBMISSIONS
(for July 2003) Submissions are requested for a science poster session entitled: "Are soils a sink or a source for atmospheric CO2?" This will be as part of the INQUA - Congress to be held July 23-31 2003, in Reno, Nevada, USA. The poster session will focus on the following issues related to impact of atmospheric CO2 on climate: 1) The contents and dynamics of pedogenic carbonate in different soils during the Pleistocene. 2) The regional and global balance of CO2 sinks and emissions from soils. 3) The
fate of CO2 in soils under the different climates of Pleistocene. Information on the INQUA Congress is available at: http://www.dri.edu/DEES/INQUA2003/inqua home.htm For further information please contact Yaroslav G. Ryskov, Institute of Physico-Chemical and Biological Problem of Soil Science RAS. E-mail: ryskov@ issp.serpukhov.su Fax: (70967)79 05 95

(July, 2002, Queensland)
Innovation in Action - 2002 State Conference Landcare and Catchment Management

Contact: David Wood Burdekin Dry Tropics Group Implementation Officer Phone: 07 4721 4303 burdekindrytropics@bigpond.com
The Landcare State Conference will be held from 20-23 July 2002 in Townsville on the Breakwater Marina overlooking Magnetic Island in North Queensland. The theme is Innovation in Action. An opportunity for people involved in landcare, natural resource management and nature conservation to share knowledge and experiences. The conference program promises to cater for a diverse range of interests including sustainable production, nature conservation and vibrant communities. Program and registration form
at http://www.burdekindrytropics.org.au/conference.htm

(3 May, 2002)
Detection of Anthropogenic Climate Change in the Australian Region
Prof David Karoly, Monash University
CSIRO DAR Lecture Theatre, Aspendale Contact: Wenju.Cai@csiro.au
Summary: The recent Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reported that there has been an increase of about 0.6C in the global-mean temperature over the last century, with 1998 being the warmest year in the last 100 years. The IPCC Assessment concluded that
most of the observed warming over the last 50 years was likely to have been due to anthropogenic factors; increasing greenhouse gases and sulphate aerosols in the atmosphere. All studies that have successfully detected an anthropogenic influence on recent climate change have considered global scale variations. It is harder to identify the effects of anthropogenic climate change on regional scales than on global scales because of the greater magnitude of the internal climate variability relative to forced climate change signals.

The results from a regional climate change detection and attribution study over Australia will be described. Observed climate variability and change in the Australian region will be compared with climate model simulations of natural and anthropogenically-forced climate variations over the 20th century. A number of simple indices of climate variability and change are defined, including the area-mean temperature over land, the land-ocean temperature contrast, and the mean diurnal cycle and annual cycle of temperature over land. These indices are all expected to show a common response to increasing greenhouse gases but are reasonably independent for natural climate variations. The simulated interannual variability and
correlation structure of the indices, averaged over the Australian region, compare reasonably well with the observed indices. The observed trends over the last 50 years in all the indices over Australia are consistent with simulated trends in model experiments that include increasing greenhouse gas and sulphate aerosol concentrations. The observed mean warming over the last 50 years is not consistent with internal climate variability. Hence, it is likely that a significant fraction of the observed warming in the Australian region over the last 50 years is due to human activity.

(May, 2002, UK)
2nd Annual Emissions Trading - the commercial and financial implications
May 20-21, 2002, Thistle Tower Hotel, London E1. This two day conference, organised by Euromoney Energy Events, will bring together the most experienced decision-makers in the emissions trading sector and will provide you with an excellent insight into this rapidly growing market. You will learn about the future of the international markets and will have an opportunity to network with the leaders of the industry. website www.euromoneyenergy.com or Contact: Euromoney Energy Events, Nestor House, Playhouse Yard, London EC4V 5EX, Tel: +44 20 7779 8103, email: energyevents@euromoneyplc.com.

(May, 2002, USA)
GREEN TRADING SUMMIT
Arranged by Global Change Associates and the MYA Group, this conference addresses the convergence of emissions markets, renewables and energy efficiency trading in a risk management context. The conference will be held in New York City on 14 and 15 May. Topics include SO2, NOx, and CO2 trading as well as renewable energy credit and negawatt trading. For further information, see: http://www.global-change.com/conferences.html

(April 2002)
S Subunit of Photosystem 2 (PsbS) and its Function in Regulating Photosynthetic Light Harvesting
Dr Xiao-Ping Li, Dept of Plant and Microbial Biology, Univ of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-3102 USA.
When: 11.15 am, 29th April; Where: Robertson Seminar Room, RSBS, ANU, Canberra; Contact: Michael.Roderick@anu.edu.au Ph 02 6125 4020
Overview: In the photosynthetic apparatus, light absorption, utilization, and dissipation have to be well regulated. Nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ) dissipates absorbed light energy as heat before it reaches the photosynthetic reaction centers and thus plays a critical role in the regulation process. In vivo, NPQ is xanthophyll dependent and is regulated by the pH gradient across the thylakoid membrane. The fast induction and relaxation characteristics of NPQ are consistent with its importance for plants grown in natural, fluctuating environmental conditions, and NPQ exists in all land plants studied. By screening Arabidopsis for NPQ-deficient mutants, we found the 22 kD photosystem II subunit (PsbS) is absolutely necessary for NPQ. In npq4-1, a psbS deletion mutant, the rapidly relaxing (in time scale of seconds to minutes) NPQ is totally abolished, whereas the xanthophyll cycle and the photosynthetic electron
transport are normal. Genetic analysis indicated that psbS has a dosage effect on NPQ. Further studies showed that the capacity of NPQ is determined by the amount of PsbS protein and PsbS protein level is
determined by psbS gene copy number. Overexpressing psbS increased the amount of PsbS in the thylakoid membrane and increased NPQ capacity without changing other light-harvesting proteins. Plants with higher NPQ are more resistant to high light stress. Site-directed mutagenesis studies have identified two lumen-facing amino acid residues, E122 and E226, which might work as pH gradient

(April, 2002, Victoria)
The Political Economy of Climate Change
Presented: 23 April, CSIRO DAR Lecture Theatre, Aspendale Contact: Wenju.Cai@csiro.au
By Dr. Clive Hamilton, Executive Director of The Australia Institute for a Just, Sustainable and Peaceful Future, ANU

(April, 2002, Victoria)
The role of modern Earth science in sustainability programs
Prof. Mutter, Executive Deputy Director, Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory of Columbia University, USA
CSIRO DAR Lecture Theatre, Aspendale Contact: Wenju.Cai@csiro.au
Prof. Mutter was asked to present an overview of some of the programs put together at Columbia to address the issues of role of modern Earth science in sustainability programs.

(April, 2002)
De-coupling economic growth from environmental degradation through eco-efficiency and communication
.
Nordic PrepCom III WSSD side-event held Wed March 27 Contact: Helen Agren new-york.delegate32@foreign.ministry.se
Arranged by the Govts of Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden Moderator: Ambassador Bohn, Swedish Ministry for Foreign Affairs. Program included:

  • De-coupling - the key challenge for changing production and consumption patterns - Astrid Jacobsen, Danish Ministry for the Environment
  • Eco efficiency as a means of achieving decoupling - Mikko Jalas, Helsinki School of Economics
  • Cooperation for a product-oriented environmental policy - Helen Agren, Swedish Env. Protection Agency
  • Practical use of life-cycle data and analysis: presentation of Environmental Product Declarations - Sven-Olof Ryding, Swedish Env. Management Council

(March, 2002, South Australia)
Sustaining Our Communities, Local Agenda 21 Conference [http://www.adelaide.sa.gov.au/soc/]
More than 400 people from more than 100 Local Government Authorities came together in Adelaide 3-6 March to discuss and develop their approaches to sustainability. Contact: John Salter, Strategic Environment Officer, Adelaide City Council Tel: 0417 050 910 or ( (08) 8203 7751; mailto: J.Salter@adelaidecitycouncil.com; http://www.adelaidecitycouncil.com Snailmail:GPO Box 2252 Adelaide SA 5001

NEW EARTH REPORT TV SERIES ON BBC TO FOCUS ON SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
UNEP INFORMATION NOTE
[www.unep.org] LONDON, NAIROBI - The United Nations Environment Programme is the sponsor of a new BBC series of Earth Report which will begin in April and continue until August this year to coincide with the United Nations World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) to be held in Johannesburg (26 August-4 September). The new instalment in the series made by the Television Trust for the Environment (TVE), will be fully interactive. On the eve of the Summit, TVE will stage a special Earth Report debate featuring the leading players at Johannesburg. Earth Report is broadcast five times per week GMT on Monday at 22.30, Tuesday at 09.30 and 14.30, Wednesday at 02.30 a.m. and Saturday at 1930. For local broadcast times consult www.bbcworld.com Contact: earthreport@tve.org.uk or TVE website at www.tve.org

 

ARTICLES & PRESS RELEASES OF INTEREST

STUDY OF TREE RINGS REVEALS CLIMATE HISTORY
CNN March 22, 2002 Internet: http://www.cnn.com/2002/TECH/science/03/22/tree.rings.ap/index.html
An unusually warm period a millennium ago may have been part of a natural planetary cycle, U.S. and Swiss researchers say in a study of tree rings that scrutinizes the link between human activity and climate change. The study, appearing Friday in the journal Science, analyzed ancient tree rings from 14 sites on three continents in the northern hemisphere and concluded that temperatures in an era known as the Medieval Warm Period some 800 to 1,000 years ago closely matched the warming trend of the 20th century.

In recent years, many climate scientists have said an unprecedented warming spell that began last century and continues is caused by the greenhouse effect. The greenhouse effect is blamed on an increase in the atmosphere of gases, principally carbon dioxide, from the burning of fossil fuels, which
trap heat just as do glass panes in a greenhouse. The tree-ring study gives another perspective on Earth's natural cycles, said Edward Cook of the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory in Palisades, New York. Cook is co-author of the study with Jan Esper and Fritz Schweingruber of the Swiss Federal Research Institute. Cook said the study shows the Earth to be "capable of rapid changes and long periods of above average warmth on its own without greenhouse warming. "We don't use this as a refutation of greenhouse
warming," said Cook. "But it does show that there are processes within the Earth's natural climate system that produce large changes that might be viewed as comparable to what we have seen in the 20th century." Cook said the study found that, based on the growth of rings in the trunks of trees that lived hundreds of years ago, the temperatures during the Medieval Warm Period were about equal to the warming trend that started in the 20th century.

Refining predictions: "Greenhouse gases were not a factor back in the Medieval Warm Period," said Cook. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, an international group, has predicted that the current warming trend will continue deep into the 21st century, with average temperatures rising by 2.5 and 10 degrees. Based on this prediction, there have been international proposals for systematic reductions in the burning of fossil fuels. The proposal has been resisted by the United States, particularly by the Bush administration. Cook said data used in the climate change panel's calculation is based on a model that compared the preindustral age climate with the climate of the 20th century. The model did not include a Medieval Warm Period. Including data from that era could change the calculations, Cook said. "The Medieval Warm Period is in some sense comparable up to 1990 in the 20th century," said Cook. "But that does not say that the 20th century hasn't been perturbed by greenhouse gases. The real challenge is to factor out the natural variability from" man made causes of global warming. Cook said the panel's temperature warming prediction could be correct. Based on the new tree-ring data, however, he said the warming could be in the lower part of the temperature range forecast by the group. Keith Briffa
and Timothy Osborn, climate scientists at the University of East Anglia in Britain, said the study by Cook and his colleagues "provides evidence for greater climate swings in the last 1,000 years than has yet been generally accepted." In a commentary in Science, Briffa and Osborn said a need exists for more such independent studies to refine predictions for global warming in this century.

HOTTER TIMES ON PLANET EARTH, RESEARCHERS FIND
National Post 27 March 2002 Internet:http://www.nationalpost.com/search/story.html?f=/stories/20020327/463946.html&qs=climate
A team of American and Canadian researchers has found evidence of real global warming: the temperature of the Earth's crust is increasing at a remarkable rate. "We can now say we truly have global warming," says Dr. Hugo Beltrami, a geophysicist at St. Francis Xavier University in Nova Scotia. Until now most data on global warming has been gleaned from the atmosphere, polar icecaps and oceans, but Dr. Beltrami's team looked at continental rocks, which cover about 30% of the planet's surface.

The scientists studied 616 deep bore holes that had been drilled into rock formations from Africa to the Arctic and found evidence of a marked rise in temperature over the past 500 years. The surface of continental rocks are, on average, one degree Celsius warmer now than they were five centuries ago, and most of the warming has occurred since 1900, the scientists report in a paper being published in the upcoming issue of the Geophysical Research Letters, a leading geology journal. While one degree may not sound like much, Dr. Beltrami says there is now about as much heat going into the Earth from the
atmosphere as there is coming to the surface from the planet's hot molten core. The warming is most pronounced in northern latitudes, Dr. Beltrami says. On Ellesmere Island and in laska, ground temperatures are four to five degrees higher than they were in 1500. The rise is having a significant effect on permafrost, turning some northern areas that were once perpetually frozen into "several metres of muck," he says.

Dr. Beltrami and his colleagues from the University of Michigan found that more than half of the land's heat gain over the past 500 years came during the 20th century, and 30% since 1950. The new data from the rocks fits with evidence from the oceans and atmosphere showing that all major parts of the Earth's climate system have warmed over the past half-century. The geophysicist's conclusion means that the warming has been truly global. Dr. Beltrami says the historic temperature profile of bore holes is a more reliable reflection of warming trends than tree rings because heat absorbed from the atmosphere by rocks slowly permeates the Earth, leaving a distinct signature in the temperature profile of the rocks as it moves down. "We can plot the heat actually going into the ground," he says. Heat absorbed 100 years ago is now about 150 metres deep, and heat from 300 years ago is between 250-300 metres below ground, depending on the type of rock. The bore holes were up to one kilometre deep, and had been drilled by mining companies and geologists. Greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide generated by the burning of fossil fuels, are believed by many scientists to be responsible for the global warming trend. While the
thought of warmer weather in Nova Scotia or Saskatchewan may sound appealing, scientists predict the warming will bring with it a rise in the number of so-called "extreme weather events" such as ice storms, droughts and hurricanes. "That's what worries me the most," Dr. Beltrami says.

(April, 2002)
U.S. MOVES TO OUST HEAD OF GLOBAL WARMING PANEL
International Herald Tribune April 3, 2002 Internet: http://www.iht.com/articles/53401.html
After a year of urging from energy industry lobbyists, the Bush administration is seeking the removal of an American scientist who for nearly six years has directed an international panel of hundreds of experts
assessing global warming, several government officials have said. The specialist, Robert Watson, chief scientist of the World Bank, is highly regarded as an atmospheric chemist by many climate experts. He has held the unpaid position of chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change since fall 1996. Now his term is expiring, and the State Department has chosen not to renominate him to head the panel, which is run under the auspices of the United Nations and the World Meteorological Organization.

Watson is an outspoken advocate of the idea that human actions - mainly burning oil and coal - are contributing to global warming and must be changed to avert environmental upheavals. Energy industry lobbyists and some Republican elected officials in the United States have criticized him as biased and focused on building a scientific argument to justify cutting the use of coal and oil. Monday night, a State Department official said the Bush administration was leaning toward endorsing a scientist from India, which along with other developing countries has been eager for a stronger role in the climate assessments.

Rajendra Pachauri, an Indian engineer and economist who is now one of five vice chairmen, is the only other significant candidate nominated for panel chairman. He is highly regarded by many, but many scientists said his lack of grounding in atmospheric science made him an unsuitable choice. Nevertheless several lobbyists for energy companies and auto manufacturers were scheduled to meet with senior State Department officials Tuesday afternoon, when they are expected to press the administration to endorse Pachauri. One of the lobbyists said that in a two-man race, it was necessary for industry to make a choice - and that the choice should not be Watson.

(April, 2002)
CSIRO Press Releases
CSIRO tracks the world's air pollution
A new model of The Air Pollution Model (TAPM) allows environment agencies to track emissions from cities, enables operators of industrial sites to determine pollution impacts and lets researchers establish how far air pollution extends from its source. More at: http://www.csiro.au/page.asp?type=mediaRelease&id=TAPM2

US ozone award to CSIRO scientist
Dr Paul Fraser from CSIRO Atmospheric Research recently won a prestigious 2002 US EPA Ozone Protection Award. The award was made in recognition of his "exemplary efforts and achievements in protecting stratospheric ozone". Dr Fraser, an atmospheric chemist, has been measuring levels of ozone
depleting chemicals in the atmosphere since the mid-1970s. Govt and industry in Australia and overseas have used his findings to implement and track phase-out of CFCs and halons. Read more at:
http://www.csiro.au/page.asp?type=mediaRelease&id=OzoneAward

(April, 2002)
Fed Gov Press Release
COUNCIL OF AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENTS COMMUNIQUE - NATIONAL ACTION PLAN FOR
SALINITY AND WATER QUALITY AND PROPERTY RIGHTS

INTRODUCTION: The Council of Australian Governments (COAG) recently held its 11th meeting in Canberra. The Council, comprising the Australian Prime Minister, Premiers and Chief Ministers and the President of the Australian Local Government Association (ALGA), had wide ranging discussions on
important areas of national interest. This Communique sets out (some of) the agreed outcomes of the discussions: The Council reviewed progress in implementing the National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality (NAP) in Australia agreed on by COAG on 3 November 2000.

The Council noted that all jurisdictions except Western Australia have signed the Intergovernmental Agreement that sets out the overarching commitments and obligations of the NAP. The Council noted that Bilateral Agreements are in place with South Australia, Victoria, Tasmania and Queensland, that the Bilateral Agreement with New South Wales is ready for signing, and that a range of key policy tools to support the implementation of the NAP have either been agreed or substantially progressed. These
include national criteria for accrediting integrated regional Natural Resource Management plans, a national framework for Natural Resource Management standards and targets and a national monitoring and evaluation framework. Council noted that although regional planning is progressing well in South Australia, Victoria and New South Wales, there was a need for a greater urgency in this task with the objective of achieving accreditation of a significant number of plans by June this year. The Council noted that funding for priority projects in South Australia totalling $15.1 million had been provided and that foundation funding, priority actions and capacity building activities totalling $15.8 million were approved by Commonwealth and Victorian Ministers in February 2002. Council members emphasised their ongoing commitment to working with communities to undertake an integrated approach to natural resource
management on a regional scale. The Council agreed to accelerate the implementation of the NAP including by:

  • signing of the Intergovernmental Agreement by all parties that have not yet done so;
  • concluding the remaining Bilateral Agreements by the end of June 2002, including progress on foundation funding, capacity building and priority projects; and
  • making substantial progress on regional plans in all jurisdictions by the
    end of 2002.

The Council agreed to support arrangements that include adequate:

  • local government representation on regional bodies;
  • local government involvement in the development of integrated natural resource management regional plans; and
  • awareness of regional objectives in local planning.

The Council noted water has been a key driver in regional and national development and, in recognition of the need to address adverse economic and environmental consequences of past water management policies and practices, in 1994 COAG adopted a strategic framework for reforms to national water
governance. A key part of these reforms has been the development of a system of water property rights on a jurisdiction by jurisdiction basis. The Council also noted that substantial progress is being made on the national water reforms. Water management is currently in a transition phase as jurisdictions implement new water allocation arrangements. There have been a number of calls for clarification to water property rights. Council reaffirmed the importance of water property rights issues in dealing with the nation's salinity and water quality problems. Council further noted that during this transitional period, there may be a lack of information in the community about the nature of property rights, including responsibilities of water users. There also needs to be consideration of the implications of changes to water property rights for investment and the impacts of the changes on water users, particularly farmers. In order to clarify these issues jurisdictions agreed to report to COAG by September 2002 on opportunities and impediments to better define and implement water property rights regimes (including water trading markets and where appropriate the responsibilities of water users); and how they are addressing uncertainties.

(April 2002)
APPOINTMENT OF FED SCIENCE ADVISER BY FEDERAL MINISTER BRENDAN NELSON
For further information: Ross Hampton 0419 484 095 [MIN 46/02]
I am pleased to announce that Dr Thomas Barlow has accepted an appointment as my Science Adviser. Dr Barlow is a researcher and science writer with a highly credentialed background. Dr Barlow ommenced studies at the University of Sydney and completed his training at St John's College, Oxford. He continued as a Research fellow at Balliol College, Oxford for a further three years. In 1998 Dr Barlow was a Visiting Research Fellow at M.I.T. Cambridge in the United States. The focus of his research was protein structure prediction and small molecule drug design. Dr Barlow went on to be a regular contributor to the Financial Times, writing about science and its role in society. Dr Barlow will work closely with advisers
in Science Minister Peter McGauran's office, provide a contact point for peak science bodies and interested agencies and ensure that the voice of Science is heard loudly and clearly in my office.

(March 2002)
BIG ANTARCTIC ICE BREAK-OUT RAISES CLIMATE CHANGE CONCERN
[http://www.ea.gov.au/minister/ps/2002/psmr21mar02.html - Environment-news, Issue 24]
Parliamentary Secretary responsible for the Antarctic, Dr Sharman Stone, said the recent loss of an area of nearly 8800 square kilometres from the Antarctic ice sheet - more than three times the size of the Australian Capital Territory - is a disturbing reminder of the fact that global warming is a reality. A 5500 square kilometre piece of the Thwaites Glacier Tongue in West Antarctica has broken away and floated into the Amundsen Sea, southeast of Australia, producing an enormous iceberg code-named B-22.

(April, 2002)
PRESS RELEASE: CO2SIM TO BE KNOWN AS CARBONSIM
Contact Craig Windram via www.carbonsim.com
The term carbon dioxide equivalent, or CO2E, is one that we in the climate change community have been using for decades. However, since 8 September 2000 it has been a registered trade mark of e-speed Inc, a wholly owned subsidiary of Cantor Fitzgerald LLC and a partner in CO2E.COM LLC ? a company formed by the Cantor Fitzgerald group in association with PricewaterhouseCoopers. On 4 March 2002, Allens Arthur Robinson, acting on behalf of their client e-speed Inc, issued a letter addressed to CO2SIM
(Australia) Pty Ltd (our company) asserting Trade Mark Infringement, Breaches of Trade Practices Act and Passing Off. (The full text of this letter may be accessed electronically from our web page www.carbonsim.com).
Our company is a leading developer of greenhouse gas emissions trading platforms, simulations and software. Since January 2002 the company has been successfully growing its global business, providing tailored software solutions that assist clients to manage their greenhouse gas emissions liabilities. In that letter, lawyers acting on behalf of e-speed Inc asserted that CO2SIM operated a website that was "a marketplace for emissions trading?operating in competition to our client's website". And that in so doing, CO2SIM infringed e-speed's registered trade mark CO2E, engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and engaged in conduct that constituted the tort of passing off. As such, e-speed "demanded" a number
of undertakings, including that we refrain from using the mark CO2SIM, refrain from using the domain name CO2SIM.com, take steps to effect a change of the company name and deliver up to e-speed all stocks of brochures, stationery, advertising or promotional material that bears any of the company name CO2SIM (Australia) Pty Ltd, the mark CO2SIM, or the domain name CO2SIM.com.

Our company does not accept that there is any confusion between the two businesses, simply because both businesses are in a related field and both names incorporate the chemical formulation CO2. (The full text of our response may be accessed electronically via our web page www.carbonsim.com ). Our company is not a marketplace for emissions trading; rather the company is focussed upon the development of tailored software solutions that will assist companies to manage their greenhouse gas emissions liabilities and to trade in the associated emission permits, allowances or credits. We believe that this position is clear in all our corporate literature, on our website, and in the press releases that have been issued to date. However, irrespective of the rights of the case, we were faced very costly; or to capitulate to the demands of e-speed Inc. After some consideration we decided to comply with their "demands" as we are a small and innovative company that has limited resources. Faced with a choice of
spending our time on the style of our company name, or on the substance of our business, we decided to focus upon what was most important to us ? our customers and our products. This is not a decision that we took lightly, as we are people of passion and principle. Therefore from today our company will be known as CARBONSIM. Our business will continue unaffected, with simulations rolling out in Europe and the Nordic Countries in May and in Canada and Australia in June. In truth our business won't miss a beat, and we would like to thank all our clients and partners for their support during this short transition. As CARBONSIM, our company will continue to be a leading developer of greenhouse gas emissions trading platforms, simulations and software and will continue to deliver tailored software solutions that assist our clients to manage their greenhouse gas emissions liabilities.

CARBONSIM's next simulation will be held in Europe between 28th and 30th May 2002, and will be based upon the proposed European Commission's draft directive on emissions trading. The simulation will give participants a practical insight into how a future emissions trading regime might work, and what the ramifications of it might be, as well as the opportunity to evaluate the impact of different trading rules on real business scenarios and to experience the dynamics of a regional carbon market.

CLIMATE CHANGE: Kyoto Reluctance Costs Australia Millions, Firms Say
March 27 (UN Wire) http://www.unwire.org/unwire/current.asp#25047

Climate Change Spreads Drought Across Australia
March 14 (ENS) http://ens-news.com/ens/mar2002/2002L-03-14-03.html

(March, 2002)
AUSTRALIA SECURES WORLD LEADING IRON AND STEEL TECHNOLOGY

MEDIA RELEASE ISSUED BY MINISTER IAN MACFARLANE (ITR)
24 April 2002 02/065 Contact: Murray Fearn, Invest Australia, 02 6213 7560

The Commonwealth Government will provide a $125 million investment incentive to Rio Tinto to secure the commercialisation and development of its HIsmelt echnology at Kwinana, Western Australia. The Minister for Industry, Tourism and Resources, Ian Macfarlane, announced the support this morning adding that Rio Tinto has plans to invest as much as $1.2 billion in an iron ore processing plant and integrated steel operation. More than 500 new jobs would be created in the process. "The commercialisation of HIsmelt in Kwinana represents a landmark in the development of a revolutionary and largely Australian technology. Around $600 million has been spent developing this process over the last 20 years," said Mr Macfarlane.

The Commonwealth and Western Australian governments have worked cooperatively to ensure this new technology is developed in Australia rather than overseas. Rio Tinto had also been examining the possibility of building the first commercial HIsmelt plant in the United States. Rio Tinto will develop infrastructure including a co-generation plant, an industrial gas plant and water recycling facilities. All of these plants will be available to other users on commercial terms. The HIsmelt technology represents a quite different way of producing iron and steel using cheaper and lower quality raw materials, like non-coking coal and iron ore with high impurity levels. Mr Macfarlane has applauded the significant environmental improvements of this new technology. "This process is capable of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from traditional iron and steel making by between 20 and 50 per cent. The HIsmelt technology can also utilise and recycle some of the wastes produced by steel plants," he said. The HIsmelt technology doesn't use coke ovens, sinter plants or blast furnaces and emits no dioxins or furans making it significantly more greenhouse friendly than current operations. Through Rio Tinto's joint venture partners, there is a very substantial opportunity for Australia's HIsmelt technology to become widely adopted in China. Further, the technology could potentially be utilised by steel makers world-wide, resulting in significant reductions of greenhouse gas emissions related to global steel production.

(MARCH 2002)
SCIENTISTS WARN OF GLOBAL COINCIDENCE

Rising Temps, Oceans, and Greenhouse Gas Proof of Weird, Unrelated Happenings

- an amusing take on Global Warming from Satirewire.com
[Article in full at http://www.satirewire.com/news/march02/coincidence.shtml ]

Washington, D.C.? Sea levels swelled, but still they doubted. Temperatures soared, but still they questioned. Glaciers disappeared, yet even so, they refused to believe. But now, the sudden disintegration of a massive Antarctic ice shelf may convinced even the most hardened skeptics that Earth
truly is threatened by Global Coincidence. "If there was before, there can be no doubt now that there is one very obvious reason why all these things are happening," said Dr. Milton Suter of the Center for Climatological Happenstance.

"And that reason is: Because they are."

The numbers supporting Global Coincidence, Suter insisted, don't lie. In the last 100 years, while carbon dioxide and methane emissions have surged, the world's average land surface temperature has risen 1.0ºF, and the oceans have risen 6 to 8 inches. "For most people, that would be enough," Suter noted. "I mean, right there, all that adds up to a pretty strange coincidence."